[Consim-l] AP's SWAS games

Pat Collins tippecanoe8 at sbcglobal.net
Mon Feb 12 21:33:24 EST 2007


Altering subject since it's old email....

> Here are some points in the rules come to mind which people might find
> interesting in the light of how well the game reflects historical results 
> :
>
> *Some air attacks are hardly even worth the effort as they are unlikely to
> sink anything and you run the risk of losing aircraft.

Very true.  Same for attacks on airfields. And yet, if you are in a 
situation where you have no better
prospects....

> *The Long Lance torpedo is devastating and a big threat.

To me, they are not big enough of a threat. You can pump 2, 3 torpedos into 
a CA or better and not sink it. That just doesn't feel right.

I think torpedos in SWAS and GWAS are not deadly enough.

Regards, Pat
Last Played: Ardennes, ASL SK, Bitter Woods 



More information about the Consim-l mailing list